Lost Sailor Fish & Gourmet

Cuisines: Seafood

Address: 2534 Orchard Lake Rd, Sylvan Lake, MI 48320, USA

Kitchen - All Day

Signature Eats

  • Cod Fish N' Chips

    3 pieces of handcut, hand breaded, fresh never frozen Icelandic cod loin, with fries and cole slaw, tartar sauce

  • Calvisius Caviar Service

    28g tin of Calvisius Traditon Prestige Caviar (White Sturgeon), Creme Fraiche, Blinis and Better Made chips.

  • Cheeseburger & Fries

    1/2 pound griddle burger, melted Gruyere and Aged Cheddar cheese, tartar sauce and remoulade, lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun.

  • Lobster Roll

    Quarter pound of chilled Northern Atlantic lobster meat, lightly tossed in clarified butter, on a toasted brioche bun. Served with cole slaw and a bag of Better Made chips.

  • Caesar Salad

    Crisp Romaine lettuce, Lost Sailor Caesar dressing, homemade croutons, aged Parmigiano Regiano.

Soups

Sandwiches

  • Salmon Patty Sandwich

    Homemade salmon patty, sauteed and topped with mustard sauce, lettuce and tomato, on a toasted brioche bun.

  • Tuscan Tuna Melt

    Cento Italian tuna, tartar sauce and capers, lettuce, tomato, and red onion, on a toasted bun with melted aged cheddar and gruyere.

  • Fish Sandwich

    Choice of today's fresh catch, prepared blackened, simply seared, or fried. With lettuce, tomato, tartar sauce or remoulade, on a toasted brioche bun.

  • Crab Cake Sandwich

    Our housemade quarter pound crabcake, remoulade, lettuce and tomato, on a toasted brioche sandwich bun.

  • Cheeseburger & Fries

    1/2 pound griddle burger, melted Gruyere and Aged Cheddar cheese, tartar sauce and remoulade, lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun.

  • Lobster Roll

    Quarter pound of chilled Northern Atlantic lobster meat, lightly tossed in clarified butter, on a toasted brioche bun. Served with cole slaw and a bag of Better Made chips.

Salads

  • Caesar Salad

    Crisp Romaine lettuce, Lost Sailor Caesar dressing, homemade croutons, aged Parmigiano Regiano.

Appetizers

  • Crab Cake Appetizer

    Fresh Blue Crab seared to golden brown, served with remoulade sauce.

  • Smoked Whitefish Salad

    Smoked wild whitefish pate, made in house, served with toasted crostini.

Entrees

  • Cod Fish N' Chips

    3 pieces of handcut, hand breaded, fresh never frozen Icelandic cod loin, with fries and cole slaw, tartar sauce

  • Crab Cake Entree (2)

    2 handmade crabcakes (select blue crab), Arugula greens, remoulade

  • Salmon Entree

    8 ounce cut of roasted Loch Duart Salmon, coconut rice, and cole slaw.

  • Fried Shrimp Basket

    5 large fried shrimp, with fries and cole slaw, cocktail sauce

  • Walleye Fish N' Chips

  • Perch Fish & Chips

Sides

  • Coconut Rice

  • French Fries

Housemade Desserts

Kids Menu

  • Sliders and Fries

  • Kids Fish n' Chips

From our Market

Charcuterie

Accoutrement

  • Fig Spread, Dalmatia

  • Potter's Crackers, Carmelized Onion

  • Apricots, Dried

  • Olives, Kalamata

  • Pickles, Cornichons

  • Potter's Crackers, Wisconsin Rye

  • Blini

  • Fine Cheese Co. Fig Honey Crackers

  • Everybody Eat Chia Thins

  • Top Seedz Crackers, 6 Seed

  • Top Seedz Crackers, Sea Salt

  • Top Seedz Crackers, Rosemary

  • Fine Cheese Co. Chilli EVOO crackers

Dairy

  • Butter, 1 lb.

Drinks

  • Pop, Vernors

  • Pop, Diet Coke

  • Pop, Sprite

  • Pop, Coke

  • Vellamo, Still

  • Faygo Rock & Rye

  • House Lemonade

  • O'Hy Strawberry Lemon

  • Spade Guava

  • Spade Dr. Spade

  • Spade Blueberry Acai

  • Faygo Red Pop

  • Faygo Grape

  • Vellamo, Sparkling

  • House Ice Tea

  • O'hy Rasberry

  • Faygo Orange

Merch & Gifts

  • Sylvan Lake Hats, Third Coast

Chips

  • Better Made BBQ

  • Better Made Original

  • Licorice

Packaged Retail

  • Harney & Sons Chamomile

  • Cornhusker Chicken Shmaltz

  • Marcia's Cherry Pops

  • Marcia's Wild Dills

  • Harney & Sons Cherry Blossom

  • Harney & Sons Peppermint

  • Cornhusker Duck Fat

  • Cornhusker Wagyu Tallow Spray

  • Marcia's Sweet & Sassy

  • Cornhusker Beef Tallow

  • Marcia's Little Hotties

  • Cornhusker Pork Fat

  • Cornhusker Wagyu Tallow

  • Cornhusker Duck Fat Spray

  • Tabasco, large

  • Live Crispy Strawberry

  • Live Crispy Apple

  • Live Crispy Coconut

  • Live Crispy Blueberry

Shellfish

  • Heron Point Lump Crab Meat

  • Oysters

    Choice of available East or West coast oysters, shucked, served with cocktail sauce, and lemon wedge.

  • Heron Point Special Crab Meat

  • Shrimp, Key West Pink 10/15

  • Lobster CK

  • Jonah Crab Cocktial Claws

  • Maine Lobster Tails 9/10

  • Clam Strips

  • Scallops, Peruvian Bay

  • Shrimp, 13/15 Cocktail

  • Shrimp, 13/15 Raw

Tin Fish

  • Bela Mackerel in EVOO

  • Island Creek Razor Clams

  • Sea Tales Sardines in EVOO

  • La Brujula #60 Yellowfin Tuna in EVOO

  • Bela Codfish in EVOO

  • Olasagasti Yellowfin Tuna

  • Island Creek Mussels in Pickled Sauce

  • La Brujula #23 Mussels

  • Mastre Peixeiro Sardines

  • Sea Tales Sardines in Tomato

  • Sea Tales Jack Mackerel

  • Island Creek Razor Clams

  • La Brujula #80 Squids

  • Ortiz Sardines

  • La Narval Mussels

  • Jose Smoked Mackerel

  • La Narvel Sardinas

  • La Brujula #31 Sardines

  • Mar Cavalinhas Mackerel

  • Jose Smoked Small Sardines

  • Blis Smoked Albacore Tuna

  • Blis Natural Albacore Tuna

  • Great Lakes Whitefish, Sunflower Oil

Sauces

  • Horseradish

  • Cocktail Sauce

  • Caesar Dressing

  • Remoulade

  • Mustard Sauce

  • Mignonette

  • Tartar

Caviar and Cured Fish

  • Salmon Roe

  • Acme - Salty Lox

  • Mad Honey Finger Limes Chartreusse

  • Calvisius Tradition Prestige

  • White Anchovies

  • Boquerones

  • Smoked Whitefish

  • Saint Nova Smoked Salmon

  • Calvisius Siberian Royal

  • Herring, in wine sauce

Deli Salads

  • Seaweed Salad

  • Shrimp Salad

  • Chicken Salad

  • Cole Slaw

  • Tuna Salad

  • Whitefish Salad

Fish

  • Tuna, Toro (Bluefin)

  • Whitefish, filets

  • Salmon, "Loch Duart"

  • Cod Loin, Icelandic

  • White Anchovies

  • Catfish

  • Swordfish, Wild domestic

  • Walleye

  • Salmon, Loch Duart, s/ off

  • Perch, Yellow Lake

Meat

  • Fairway Burger Pack, 1 pound

  • Beef Marrow Bones

Frozen Retail

Poultry and Misc.

  • Frog Legs

Cheese

  • Humboldt Fog Goat, Cypress Grove

  • Idyl Pastures, Garlic Herb

  • Wensleydale Cranberry Cheese

  • Roth Kase Gruyere

  • Cheddar, Charlevoix "Autumn Ridge"

  • Point Reyes Blue

  • Brie, Belletoille

Prepared Retail

  • Crab cake, 4 ounce

  • Salmon patty, 5 ounce