Skip to main
Lost Sailor Fish & Gourmet
  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Specials
  • Appetizers
  • Signature Eats
  • Entrees
  • Sandwiches
  • Salads
  • Sides
  • Kids Menu
  • Drinks
  • Caviar and Cured Fish
  • Fish
  • Shellfish
  • Tin Fish
  • Charcuterie
  • Cheese
  • Accoutrement
  • Chips
  • Dairy
  • Deli Salads
  • Meat
  • Poultry and Misc.
  • Sauces
  • Produce
  • Packaged Retail
  • Prepared Retail
  • Merch & Gifts
  • Fish & Chips

Lost Sailor Fish & Gourmet Menu

2534 Orchard Lake Rd, Sylvan Lake, MI

2534 Orchard Lake Rd, Sylvan Lake, MI

·

  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Specials
  • Appetizers
  • Signature Eats
  • Entrees
  • Sandwiches
  • Salads
  • Sides
  • Kids Menu
  • Drinks
  • Caviar and Cured Fish
  • Fish
  • Shellfish
  • Tin Fish
  • Charcuterie
  • Cheese
  • Accoutrement
  • Chips
  • Dairy
  • Deli Salads
  • Meat
  • Poultry and Misc.
  • Sauces
  • Produce
  • Packaged Retail
  • Prepared Retail
  • Merch & Gifts
  • Fish & Chips

Most ordered

  • Lobster Roll.

    Lobster Roll

    $25.00

  • Cod Fish & Chips.

    Cod Fish & Chips

    $26.00

  • Clam Chowder.

    Clam Chowder

    $9.00+

  • Caesar Salad.

    Caesar Salad

    $14.00

  • Cheeseburger & Fries.

    Cheeseburger & Fries

    $21.00

  • Crab Cake Appetizer.

    Crab Cake Appetizer

    $14.00

  • French Fries.

    French Fries

    $7.00

  • Caviar Service.

    Caviar Service

    $88.00+

Specials

Lobster, egg n cheese croissant

$22.00

Shrimp Cocktail & Fries

$23.00

5 crisp shrimp served with cocktail sauce and french fries.

Appetizers

Crab Cake Appetizer

$14.00

Fresh Blue Crab with minimal Old Bay seasoning, seared to golden brown, served with remoulade sauce.

Crab Cake Appetizer.

Lobster Mac n' Cheese

$18.00

Baked 4 cheese lobster mac

Salmon Patty Appetizer

$13.00

Shrimp Cocktail

$18.00

6 large, chilled shrimp with cocktail sauce

Smoked Whitefish Salad

$17.00

Smoked wild whitefish pate, made in house, served with toasted crostini.

Clam Chowder

$9.00+

Scratch made New England Clam Chowder, with potatoes, carrots, and bacon. Served with toasted ciabatta.

Clam Chowder.

Signature Eats

Caesar Salad

$14.00

Crisp Romaine lettuce, Lost Sailor Caesar dressing, homemade croutons, aged Parmigiano Reggiano.

Caesar Salad.

Caviar Service

$88.00+

28g tin of Calvisius Tradition Prestige Caviar (White Sturgeon), Creme Fraiche, Blinis and Better Made Chips.

Caviar Service.

Cheeseburger & Fries

$21.00

1/2 pound griddled burger, melted Gruyere and Aged Cheddar cheese, tartar sauce and remoulade, lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun.

Cheeseburger & Fries.

Cod Fish & Chips

$26.00

3 pieces of handcut, hand breaded, fresh never frozen Icelandic cod loin, with fries and coleslaw, tartar sauce

Cod Fish & Chips.

Lobster Roll

$25.00

Quarter pound of chilled Northern Atlantic lobster meat, lightly tossed in clarified butter, on a toasted brioche bun. Served with cole slaw and a bag of Better Made chips.

Lobster Roll.

Entrees

Cod Fish & Chips

$26.00

3 pieces of handcut, hand breaded, fresh never frozen Icelandic cod loin, with fries and coleslaw, tartar sauce

Cod Fish & Chips.

Crab Cake Entree (2 pc)

$26.00

2 handmade crab cakes (select blue crab), Arugula greens, remoulade

Crab Cake Entree (2 pc).

Fried Perch and Cod Combo

$29.00

2 pieces of fried Icelandic Cod loin along with 2 fresh diamond filets of lake Perch. Served with fries, tartar sauce and a lemon, and coleslaw.

Fried Perch and Cod Combo.

Shrimp Basket & Chips

$23.00

5 large fried shrimp, with fries and cole slaw, cocktail sauce

Shrimp Basket & Chips.

Perch Fish & Chips

$27.00

Salmon Patty Entree

$21.00

Sandwiches

All sandwiches served with pickle, cole slaw, and your choice of Better Made chips.

Cheeseburger & Fries

$21.00

1/2 pound griddled burger, melted Gruyere and Aged Cheddar cheese, tartar sauce and remoulade, lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun.

Cheeseburger & Fries.

Crab Cake Sandwich

$17.00

Our housemade quarter pound crab cake, remoulade, lettuce and tomato, on a toasted brioche sandwich bun.

Crab Cake Sandwich.

Fish Sandwich

$19.00+

Choice of today's fresh catch, prepared blackened, simply seared, or fried. With lettuce, tomato, tartar sauce or remoulade, on a toasted brioche bun.

Lobster Roll

$25.00

Quarter pound of chilled Northern Atlantic lobster meat, lightly tossed in clarified butter, on a toasted brioche bun. Served with cole slaw and a bag of Better Made chips.

Lobster Roll.

Salmon Patty Sandwich

$16.00

Homemade salmon patty, sautéed and topped with mustard sauce, lettuce and tomato, on a toasted brioche bun.

Tuna Melt

$16.00

Sea Tales White Albacore tuna, tartar sauce and capers, lettuce, tomato, and red onion, on a toasted bun with melted gruyere.

Tuna Melt.

Salads

Caesar Salad

$14.00

Crisp Romaine lettuce, Lost Sailor Caesar dressing, homemade croutons, aged Parmigiano Reggiano.

Caesar Salad.

Sides

Coconut Rice

$7.00

Coconut Rice.

French Fries

$7.00

French Fries.

sweet potatoes

$7.00

Kids Menu

Kids Fish N' Chips

$16.00

Kids Fish N' Chips.

Kids Grilled Cheese and Fries

$12.00

Kids Grilled Cheese and Fries.

Popcorn Shrimp and Fries

$14.00

Salmon Patty Sliders and Fries

$16.00

Sliders and Fries

$12.00

Sliders and Fries.

Drinks

Faygo Grape

$2.50

Faygo Orange

$2.50

Faygo Red Pop

$2.50

Faygo Rock & Rye

$2.50

O'Hy Raspberry

$3.25

O'Hy Strawberry Lemon

$3.25

Pop, Coke

$2.50

Pop, Diet Coke

$2.50

Pop, Sprite

$2.50

Pop, Vernors

$2.50

Spade Blueberry Acai

$3.25

Spade Dr. Spade

$3.25

Spade Guava

$3.25

Vellamo, Sparkling

$3.50

Vellamo, Still

$3.50

Caviar and Cured Fish

Acme - Salty Lox

$12.75

Acme - Salty Lox.

Acme Everything Bagel Lox

$12.75

Acme Everything Bagel Lox.

Calvisius Siberian Royal

$98.00

Calvisius Tradition Prestige

$78.00

Herring, in wine sauce

$14.00

Saint Nova Smoked Salmon

$13.50

Saint Nova Smoked Salmon.

White Anchovies

$24.00

White Anchovies.

Fish

Catfish (frozen)

$15.00

Cod Loin, Icelandic

$31.00

Cod Loin, Icelandic.

Haddock

$19.00

Halibut

$38.00

Perch, Yellow Lake

$32.00

Pumpkin Swordfish

$29.00

Salmon, "Loch Duart"

$26.00

Salmon, "Loch Duart".

Salmon, Loch Duart, s/ off

$29.00

Swordfish, Wild domestic

$28.00

Tuna, Bluefin Toro (frozen)

$44.00

White Anchovies

$26.00

Whitefish, fillets

$18.00

Shellfish

Clams frozen

$21.00

Heron Point Lump Crab Meat

$21.00

Heron Point Special Crab Meat

$15.00

Kumamoto Oysters

$4.00

Lobster CK

$68.00

Lobster, Live 1.5#

$26.00

Maine Lobster Tails 9/10

$46.00

Mussels, hollander

$11.00

Oysters

$3.00+

Choice of available East or West coast oysters, shucked, served with cocktail sauce, and lemon wedge.

Oysters.

Scallops, Peruvian Bay

$27.00

Shrimp, 13/15 Cocktail

$32.00

Shrimp, 13/15 Cocktail.

Shrimp, 13/15 Raw Oishi

$22.00

Shrimp, 13/15 Black Tiger

$19.00

Shrimp, 8\10

$22.00

Shrimp, 26\30

$19.00

Shrimp, Key West Pink 10/15

$29.00

Snow Crab Clusters

$26.00

Tin Fish

Bela Codfish in EVOO

$7.95

Bela Codfish in EVOO.

Blis Natural Albacore Tuna

$14.75

Blis Natural Albacore Tuna.

Blis Smoked Albacore Tuna

$14.75

Blis Smoked Albacore Tuna.

Great Lakes Whitefish Garlic

$16.75

Great Lakes Whitefish Garlic.

Great Lakes Whitefish, Lemon Dill

$16.75

Great Lakes Whitefish, Lemon Dill.

Great Lakes Whitefish, Sunflower Oil

$16.75

Great Lakes Whitefish, Sunflower Oil.

Jose Smoked Mackerel

$13.25

Jose Smoked Mackerel.

Jose Smoked Small Sardines

$11.00

Jose Smoked Small Sardines.

La Brujula #31 Sardines

$13.50

La Brujula #31 Sardines.

La Brujula #60 Yellowfin Tuna in EVOO

$17.25

La Brujula #60 Yellowfin Tuna in EVOO.

La Narval Mussels

$9.25

La Narval Mussels.

La Narval Sardinas

$6.75

La Narval Sardinas.

Mar Cavalinhas Mackerel

$8.25

Mar Cavalinhas Mackerel.

Mastre Peixeiro Sardines

$7.50

Mastre Peixeiro Sardines.

Olasagasti Yellowfin Tuna

$17.25

Olasagasti Yellowfin Tuna.

Ortiz Sardines

$9.00

Ortiz Sardines.

Sea Tales Jack Mackerel

$6.25

Sea Tales Jack Mackerel.

Sea Tales Sardines in EVOO

$5.95

Sea Tales Sardines in EVOO.

Sea Tales Sardines in Tomato

$5.95

Sea Tales Sardines in Tomato.

Charcuterie

Dearborn Andouille Sausage

$9.75

Olli Hot Honey Salami tray

$7.50

Olli Hot Honey Salami tray.

Olli Genoa Salami tray

$7.50

Olli Genoa Salami tray.

Cheese

Brie, Belletoile

$21.00

Charlevoix Cheddar, Mild

$18.00

Idyll Pastures, Goat

$26.00

Idyll Pastures, Garlic Herb

$7.75

Parmigiano Reggiano 24 Mos

$23.00

Roth Kase Buttermilk Blue

$18.00

Roth Kase Gruyere

$17.00

Accoutrement

Blini

$11.25

Blini.

Everybody Eat Chia Thins

$7.75

Fine Cheese Co. Chilli EVOO Crackers

$8.50

Fine Cheese Co. Fig Honey Crackers

$8.50

Olives, Frescatrano

$17.00

Pickles, Cornichons

$2.75

Pickles, Cornichons.

Potter's Crackers, Caramelized Onion

$7.95

Potter's Crackers, Wisconsin Rye

$7.95

Top Seedz Crackers, 6 Seed

$9.50

Top Seedz Crackers, 6 Seed.

Top Seedz Crackers, Rosemary

$9.50

Top Seedz Crackers, Rosemary.

Top Seedz Crackers, Sea Salt

$9.50

Top Seedz Crackers, Sea Salt.

Chips

Better Made BBQ

$1.50

Better Made SMALL

$1.50

Licorice

$3.00

Dairy

Butter, 1 lb.

$5.25

Deli Salads

Cole Slaw

$9.00

Pasta Salad

$13.00

Potato Salad

$12.00

Seaweed Salad

$14.00

Shrimp Salad

$29.00

Tuna Salad

$18.00

Whitefish Salad

$29.00

Meat

Beef Marrow Bones

$11.00

Fairway Burger Pack, 1 pound

$15.00

Pork Chop, Beeler's

$22.00

Ribeye, Wagyu Tomahawak

$48.00

Tomahawk, Fairway 28 day DA

$125.00

Poultry and Misc.

Frog Legs

$16.00

Sauces

Caesar Dressing

$4.00+

Cocktail Sauce

$2.00+

Horseradish

$1.50+

Mignonette

$1.50+

Mustard Sauce

$3.00+

Remoulade

$3.00+

Tartar

$1.50+

Extra Side Cole Slaw

$1.00

Produce

Celery

$2.95

Cucumbers

$2.00

Lemons

$0.50

Potatoes, Red A

$3.00

Romaine Head

$6.00

Tomatoes

$4.00

Packaged Retail

Cornhusker Beef Tallow

$19.00

Cornhusker Chicken Schmaltz

$19.00

Cornhusker Duck Fat

$20.00

Cornhusker Duck Fat Spray

$15.00

Cornhusker Pork Fat

$20.00

Cornhusker Wagyu Tallow

$21.00

Cornhusker Wagyu Tallow Spray

$17.00

Harney & Sons Chamomile

$8.25

Harney & Sons Cherry Blossom

$8.25

Harney & Sons Peppermint

$8.25

Laudemio Olive Oil

$41.00

Live Crispy Apple

$7.75

Live Crispy Apple.

Live Crispy Blueberry

$7.75

Live Crispy Blueberry.

Live Crispy Coconut

$7.75

Live Crispy Coconut.

Live Crispy Strawberry

$7.75

Live Crispy Strawberry.

Marcia's Cherry Pops

$11.00

Marcia's Little Hotties

$11.00

Marcia's Sweet & Sassy

$11.00

Marcia's Wild Dills

$11.00

Tabasco, Large

$7.00

Prepared Retail

Crab Cake, 4 Ounce

$11.00

Salmon Patty, 5 Ounce

$10.00

Merch & Gifts

Skin Linen, Sailor's Balm

$44.00

Skin Linen, Sailor's Balm.

Sylvan Lake Hats, Third Coast

$39.00

Sylvan Lake Hats, Third Coast.

Fish & Chips

Cod Fish & Chips

$26.00

3 pieces of handcut, hand breaded, fresh never frozen Icelandic cod loin, with fries and coleslaw, tartar sauce

Cod Fish & Chips.

Fried Perch and Cod Combo

$29.00

2 pieces of fried Icelandic Cod loin along with 2 fresh diamond filets of lake Perch. Served with fries, tartar sauce and a lemon, and coleslaw.

Fried Perch and Cod Combo.

Shrimp Basket & Chips

$23.00

5 large fried shrimp, with fries and cole slaw, cocktail sauce

Shrimp Basket & Chips.
Sylvan Lake

Menu

Catering

Our Story

We're Hiring

Gift Cards

Contact Us

Terms of serviceAccessibility

TFB Fish Monger LLC 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner